I was never a huge fan of canned baked beans, so it never occurred to me to make them from scratch. This reinterpretation of the classic BBQ dish has totally changed my mind. I would make these any time of the year, and eat them over brown rice. They’re that yummy! This recipe makes enough for a BBQ crowd, so if it’s just one or two of you in the house and you don’t want to be eating beans forever, halve the recipe.
Working on this post I realized that I knew nothing about baked beans—that most homely and simple of dishes—so I boned up on them. I had no idea that navy beans are native to North America, made their way over to Europe, and then returned. Some regions make them with maple syrup, some with molasses. The Brits and the Irish eat them over toast, and Heinz is the most popular brand across the pond.
What I like about my version is that it was easy to make, low in sugar, not too sweet, and the depth of flavor from cooking the beans from scratch (via the OMG Beany-Brothy Deliciousness method) creates an end product that’s nothing like canned beans.
Aren’t these individual servers cute? I got them in France last year. I had a bit of extra sauce left over, which was great on BBQ sandwiches.
Traditional recipes call for bacon, sugar, ketchup, and mustard, producing a side dish that’s high in fat, sodium, and includes high-fructose corn syrup. Since this is why I avoid HFCS, making them from scratch is the way to go. I used canned organic tomato paste (no salt added) in place of the ketchup (an iconic “American” food that originated in Indonesia), and used low-glycemic Organic Coconut Sugar instead of brown sugar. Liquid smoke and smoked paprika stand in for the bacon. Husband Tested and Approved!
Suitable for:
vegan, gluten-free, low-sodium, reduced-sugar diets
Not for:
migraine diets
All of our recipes are gluten-free, sugar-free, and made with plant-based ingredients to help you build a healthy life. We support Meatless Monday. Look for midweek posts on meditation, service, and life lessons, helping you create inner balance.
How to make baked beans
Ingredients
- 1 pound white beans dried (450 g), cooking instructions below (Method #1) OR
- 64 ounces navy beans cooked, organic, rinsed and drained (Method #2)
- 6 ounces tomato paste organic, no salt added
- 1/2 cup molasses dark (omit for diabetic diet)
- 1/4 cup coconut sugar (organic)
- 1 tbsp mustard (dry)
- 2 tsp liquid smoke
- 2 tsp smoked paprika
- 2 tbsp apple cider vinegar
Instructions
Method #1: From scratch
- Cook the beans using the OMG Beany Brothy Deliciousness method. Omit the salt if on low-sodium diet.
- Remove bay leaves, celery, carrots, herb bundle, and 6 cups of the broth from the oven-safe pot.
- Preheat the oven to 300F/150C/gas mark 2.
- Stir in everything except the vinegar. Bring to a boil on the stove, then put in the oven and bake, uncovered. Check after 30 minutes. You might be happy with it at this point, or wish to cook it for another hour or two. The sauce will continue to thicken and sweeten. Stir in the vinegar when you remove the beans from the oven.
Method #2: Canned beans
- If using canned beans, rinse and drain them, then add them to an oven-safe pot with 2 C. (500 ml) filtered water.
- Preheat the oven to 300F/150C/gas mark 2.
- Stir in everything except the vinegar. Bring to a boil on the stove, then put in the oven and bake, uncovered. Check after 30 minutes. You might be happy with it at this point, or wish to cook it for another hour or two. The sauce will continue to thicken and sweeten. Stir in the vinegar when you remove the beans from the oven.
Notes
- 149 calories
- 0 g fat
- 0 g cholesterol
- 20 mg sodium
- 778 mg potassium
- 30 g carbohydrate
- 5 g fiber
- 11 g sugars
- 7 g protein
- 3 Weight Watchers Points Plus
Secretly simple baked beans from Real Simple magazine
Ginger Molasses Baked Beans from A Food Centric Life
Dorothy's Best Ever Quick Baked Beans from Shockingly Delicious
Chile baked beans from What Would Cathy Eat?
Mango BBQ beans from What Would Cathy Eat?
These beans look so yummy and so healthy. Great for a summer cookout!
Thanks so much for stopping by and commenting Liz.
I love that you remade this traditional fat & sugar-filled recipe! It sounds super tasty. I’m going to add this to my to-make list.
Thanks Barbara. Let me know if you make them. They really are deliciously easy.
This looks good Stephanie! I love the addition of liquid smoke.
Thanks Brandon!
[…] packages here. You can use 1/2 kilo in this recipe, and it will turn out just fine. For my baked beans, I used small white beans, but navy beans or any kind of small brownish or white bean will […]
Does this recipe freeze well?
Maggie, I haven’t tried freezing it but my guess is yes. Let me know if you try it.
[…] out the Homemade Classic Baked Beans from the Recipe Renovator blog to slim down the traditional recipe without compromising taste or […]
I can vouch for the deliciousness of these beans!
Glad you and Larry enjoyed them, Liz the Chef!
Stephanie,
You can’t know how timely these bean recipes are for me. :) I’m not a huge fan of cooking but insulin issues for both me and my daughter are forcing my hand.
One of the few things I truely love to make is soup. I’ve also been trying to add a couple of vegetarian meals a week for the whole fam.
Thanks again, I know I will be trying these bean recipes.
Kel
Kel, so happy to share them at a good time for you. Sorry to hear about insulin issues but if you address it early you can avoid a lifetime of trouble for both of you. Enjoy and I always love seeing pix of people’s dishes!
It sounds like a lot of work and I’m confused. I cook the beans, then add the sauce and cook longer? And if I used canned beans and boil them, do I drain the water before baking? Do I bake them in that case, then add the sauce and cook more?
Also, and more importantly, do you have information on the nutritional content? Like calories, fat and protein content? I know beans are supposed to be high in protein. I’m wondering if this might be a good way to increase by protein intake if it’s reasonable in calorie content.
Hi Nate, sorry for any confusion. Thanks for letting me know that the instructions needed some work! I’m going to edit the instructions and hopefully that will answer all your questions. (I also forgot to put some links in, so that didn’t help.)
Yes, beans are high in protein and low in fat, and this recipe adds very little fat. I don’t do nutrition analyses on my recipes, as the programs that do it are not terribly dependable, especially for harder-to-source ingredients. Plus I also do all my recipes in metric for my overseas readers and that’s as much time as I can devote to it. Let me know if my edits still don’t explain it well enough.
As to the “a lot of work”… well, I am home a lot, and cooking like this is something I do when I’m doing a bunch of other things. So the hands-on time really is fairly minimal, it’s not like making risotto where you have to stand over it for 45 minutes stirring. You sort the beans, rinse, drain, and soak overnight. Then you rinse and add a few things to the pot (maybe 10 minutes?). Then turn it on, bring to a boil, then simmer for a long time. And so on. If you’re around on a weekend, you can easily make these on a Saturday or a Sunday morning, so long as you remember to put the beans in to soak the night before. It’s also way cheaper and much tastier!
That looks good! I have never used coconut sugar, and now I must hunt it down because it sounds great.
It’s a nice, less sweet, substitute for brown sugar. Doesn’t give you that sugar rush because it’s low on the glycemic index. I am excited to try making cookies with it.
I buy my Coconut Sugar at Sprouts Farmer’s Market and online at Nuts.com, http://nuts.com/cookingbaking/sweeteners/natural-sugar-replacements/palm-sugar.html. It works great as a brown sugar and regular sugar replacement.
Thanks Maggie!